Spotify Strips 500,000+ Streams From Hit Song After Kalshi Prediction Market Manipulation Triggers $3M in Payouts
Spotify removed more than 500,000 streams from Malcolm Todd's 'Earrings' after the song's sudden No. 1 climb on the platform's daily U.S. chart was linked to suspicious activity on Kalshi — a CFTC-regulated prediction market where users stake real money on which song will top Spotify's monthly U.S. streams. By the time Spotify stripped the artificial plays, the manipulated chart position had already settled a Kalshi contract that attracted roughly $3 million in total trading, and Kalshi had already paid out winning bettors. Spotify confirmed it 'spotted and removed' the plays and demanded both Kalshi and Polymarket remove its logo from their platforms, while a Spotify source told The Hollywood Reporter the company would add 'additional checks to the charts before they're published.' There is no suggestion Todd or his team was involved; the suspicious activity was flagged to Spotify by a Kalshi trader who analyzes streaming data to place bets and questioned how the one-day surge was possible. Kalshi's COO noted music trading on the platform had already topped $400 million in 2026 as of April.
THE BREAKDOWN
This case exposes a new financial incentive loop for stream manipulation: if a trader can bet millions on which song hits No. 1, the cost-benefit of purchasing fake streams improves dramatically and the winnings can easily exceed the manipulation cost. For talent managers, chart appearances that look like algorithmic breakouts now need to be cross-referenced against prediction market activity before being used as leverage in label or brand deal negotiations — an inflated chart position could attract a Spotify audit even if the artist's own streams were legitimate. For artists with real organic momentum, a suspicious betting surge on their Kalshi contract could trigger stream removals that kneecap chart positions they legitimately earned. Agents should proactively contact Kalshi and Polymarket to verify no open contracts exist on clients' songs without authorization; Spotify's post-settlement verification gap — where payouts happen before stream audits — is a structural exploit that will attract repeat attempts.
Get the full briefing weekly
Read by talent managers, agents, and brand partnership professionals every Friday.