Bluesky CEO Jay Graber Steps Down, Toni Schneider Named Interim CEO
Bluesky CEO Jay Graber announced Monday she is stepping down to become chief innovation officer, shifting her focus to product development and decentralized protocol work. Former Automattic CEO and True Ventures partner Toni Schneider joins as interim CEO while the board conducts a permanent search. Graber has led Bluesky since August 2021, when it was still a project inside Twitter under Jack Dorsey. The app reached 40 million users following a surge after the 2024 US election but has slowed considerably since, adding only 10 million users in the seven months after the initial post-election spike. Meta's Threads is now at 400 million monthly active users.
Why it matters
Bluesky's leadership change is a signal that the decentralized social experiment has hit a scaling problem it cannot solve through product innovation alone. For brands and creators evaluating whether to build a Bluesky presence, the CEO change combined with slowing growth should lower the urgency: the platform needs a business model and a growth strategy, and a permanent CEO search takes months. Threads at 400 million MAU is now the established Twitter alternative for creators and brands looking outside X, and the investment calculus should reflect that. The more interesting question is whether Schneider, who built Automattic's distributed media model, pursues a monetization layer on top of the AT Protocol that could make Bluesky attractive to creators. That development is worth tracking before committing any meaningful budget to the platform.
Get the full briefing weekly
Read by talent managers, agents, and brand partnership professionals every Friday.